I am highly suspicious of the number of generic positive remarks I'm getting on my analytic philosophy essays. These are essays that I am deeply ashamed of, essays that I had to drag my eyes to the computer screen to proofread, because I'd cringe at every other false leap of logic or strained sentence. I am probably deeply ashamed of most of what I write anyway, but usually I do get criticisms. There doesn't seem to be a good way of telling the grader to say more negative things.